Request Free Consultation
Birmingham personal injury attorneys at Drake Injury Lawyers

Do I Have to Pay My Health Insurance Back After a Car Accident?

Posted on August 17, 2023

After an auto accident, injury victims may receive significant medical treatment covered by their health insurance plan. However, many insurers have post-settlement reimbursement rights for the bills they pay relating to crash injuries and losses.

While repayment is not automatic, understanding when and how much health insurers may recover is important for those who receive compensation from an at-fault driver’s liability insurer after settlement.

Navigating subrogation and reimbursement privileges after a serious accident involves complicated legal and financial factors. Payment timelines, calculation methods, reduction allowances, and lien negotiation techniques all come into play.

Having clarity on health insurer repayment rights and proactive strategies to potentially lower reimbursement obligations is key to maximizing recovery for victims who also have health insurance bills to repay from their collision-related settlements.

In this article, personal injury attorney Whit Drake will examine how post-accident health insurance reimbursement works, when repayment must occur, and proven methods for reducing the amount owed back to insurers from settlement proceeds.

How Post-Accident Health Insurance Reimbursement Works

Understanding a few key concepts is important for the reimbursement process:

  • Subrogation and Liens: Health plans can seek repayment from liable parties for medical bills paid through rights called subrogation and liens. These grant them recovery privileges from settlement proceeds.
  • Calculating Amount Owed: The amount potentially owed back is generally based on the medical expenses the health insurer paid relating to accident injuries and treatment, subject to state law limits.
  • Privileging Victim Compensation: Most states follow the “made whole” doctrine which requires the injured victim to be fully compensated first out of any settlement before the insurer can seek repayment of remaining funds for their lien.

While health insurers have repayment rights, there are still advantages for the insured such as receiving their full compensation first and opportunities to reduce the amounts ultimately repaid.

When Repayment Must Be Made

Determining precisely when health insurance must be repaid after an auto accident injury settlement is dictated by applicable state laws, but there are some general principles and preferred timelines for the victim’s rights that commonly apply.

Best practices generally privilege fully compensating the injured party first out of any third-party settlement funds recovered before the health insurer can seek repayment of any amounts remaining.

This aligns with the “made whole” doctrine followed in most states, which requires the injured victim to be made financially whole by fully covering their losses before insurer reimbursement occurs. Additionally, if the comparative fault is found to have reduced the total settlement amount, proportionate reductions to the health insurer’s potential repayment are permitted in many states.

Importantly, attorney fees and case-related legal costs are typically permitted to be deducted proportionately from the gross settlement amount before calculating the scaled-back reimbursement amount owed to the insurer. So in summary, full victim compensation, proportional fault reductions, and equitable pro-rata legal cost deductions often apply before determining repayment.

The nuances of timelines and calculations are dictated by individual state laws. However, experienced personal injury attorneys ensure health insurers are reimbursed properly without infringing on the victim’s rights to maximize recovery first and foremost.

Strategies to Reduce Amount Owed

There are proven techniques to potentially lower health insurance repayment amounts:

  1. Disputing Causation of Expenses: Identifying and disputing any charges not directly resulting from crash injuries.
  2. Leveraging State Laws: Many state laws favor the victim’s rights to deduction, reductions, and privilege full compensation.
  3. Negotiating Lien Discounts: Health plans may agree to reduce lien amounts to ensure repayment from the settlement.
  4. Settlement Structure:Allocating larger settlement portions to categories of damages like pain and suffering that insurers have difficulty enforcing reimbursement against can reduce amounts owed.

While insurers have reimbursement rights, working with experienced attorneys leveraging regulatory frameworks, legal precedents, lien negotiations, and creative settlement structures can significantly minimize the amount health plans ultimately recover.

FAQs on Reimbursing Health Insurance

Does health insurance have a right to repayment after an auto accident settlement?

Yes, many health plans have subrogation rights entitling them to repayment for medical bills they covered after an accident.

Can I negotiate with my health insurer after a car accident?

You may be able to negotiate discounted repayment rates with health insurers from your settlement amount.

How is the amount I owe my health insurance calculated?

It is generally based on the medical expenses they paid related to the car accident, subject to state laws capping repayment.

When do I have to reimburse health insurance from an auto settlement?

Reimbursement is typically owed only after you have been fully compensated yourself first from the settlement funds.

Can attorney fees be deducted before repaying health insurance?

Yes, attorneys fees and costs can usually be deducted proportionately before calculating the amount owed back to a health insurer.

Can I deduct the reduction amount before paying back my health insurance?

If you received a reduced settlement, the insurer’s share may also be reduced proportionately in many states.

Does car insurance have to reimburse health insurance?

Yes, if the at-fault driver’s auto liability insurer paid you, they typically must honor liens and directly repay your health insurer.

What if I don’t pay back my health insurance after the settlement?

Failure to repay health insurance from settlement proceeds, if obligated, could result in lawsuits or policy cancellation in some cases.

How soon must health insurance be repaid after I receive settlement funds?

Timelines for reimbursement vary, but often within 30 days of receiving settlement proceeds.

Can I negotiate health insurance subrogation before my car accident claim?

Yes, it is advisable to proactively negotiate discounted subrogation terms before settling your injury claim.

Don’t Let Insurers Take More Than They Should – Consult Drake Law Firm

Settling your car accident injury claim should fully compensate you first before health insurers seek repayment. Personal injury attorney, Whit Drake will protect your rights when resolving lien obligations.

We reduce reimbursement amounts utilizing strategies like disputing unjustified charges, maximizing state law protections, negotiating discounts, and strategic settlement allocation.

With proven techniques and relentless negotiation, we can optimize your recovery while fulfilling fair repayment responsibilities. Don’t let insurers take more than the law allows. Call (205) 859-2236 or complete our secure online form to schedule your free case review now.

Let us handle the complicated reimbursement details – you deserve to focus on healing and restoration.

Drake Injury Lawyers
Average rating:  
 0 reviews