Request Free Consultation
Birmingham personal injury attorneys at Drake Injury Lawyers

How Much Can I Sue For Emotional Distress?

Posted on August 17, 2023

When a negligent party’s wrongdoing inflicts mental suffering and anguish, victims may have grounds for an emotional distress claim as part of their overall personal injury compensation.

Emotional distress claims seek financial compensation for diagnosed psychological damages like depression, anxiety, PTSD, and more resulting from the defendant’s actions. Understanding what qualifies for emotional distress compensation and practical limits on amounts under the law is important for harm victims contemplating litigation.

Personal injury attorney Whit Drake will cover key considerations for viable emotional distress claims and provide an overview of typical settlement ranges based on case specifics.

With awareness of legal qualification criteria, documentation needs, settlement factors, and potential award amounts, victims can make informed decisions when including emotional damages as part of their injury claims.

Types of Emotional Distress Claims

There are two main categories of civil emotional distress claims:

  • Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress: Where psychological trauma results from the defendant’s negligent rather than intentional wrongful acts. For example, PTSD after a car accident.
  • Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress: Where extreme, intentional conduct meant to cause mental anguish prompts emotional damages. For example, a harassment campaign.

The first relates to a byproduct of negligent conduct while the second involves harm deliberately inflicted. The qualifications and eligibility criteria tend to be stricter for negligent compared to intentional infliction claims. Understanding these distinctions is important, as emotional distress claims cannot be generalized.

Key Steps in an Emotional Distress Lawsuit

Pursuing compensation for emotional distress damages requires strategic preparation and evidence of key legal elements. As a threshold matter, the underlying incident causing mental anguish must have arisen from some form of legally recognized wrongdoing by the defendant, such as negligence or intentional misconduct.

Demonstrating Dutiful Conduct

Showing that the plaintiff acted normally and reasonably leading up to the distressing incident caused by the defendant. This requires providing background evidence of responsible behavior, absence of provocation, and lack of preexisting similar mental health conditions prior to the incident sparking distress.

Gathering Evidence

Collecting medical records, mental health treatment history, testimony on observable changes, and accident details to substantiate trauma claims. Witness accounts from friends, colleagues, and family corroborating sudden personality shifts or destructive behavior changes following the incident provide powerful causation support.

Using Experts and Witnesses

Mental health experts like psychiatrists and psychologists can provide clinical evaluations and testimony causally linking the diagnosed emotional distress to the incident circumstances. Firsthand lay witnesses offer corroborating accounts of visible effects on the plaintiff’s well-being, personality, relationships, and more after the trauma occurred.

Overcoming Legal Time Limits

Filing within statutory limits for personal injury claims, typically 1-3 years depending on state law. Plaintiffs should consult local attorneys to verify precise time windows and eligibility factors, as failing to file suit could completely preclude compensation recovery.

Meeting eligibility criteria, proving causation, providing supporting evidence from professionals, and acting promptly are all essential for crafting a compelling emotional distress claim within the stringent legal parameters.

Limits and Factors on Emotional Distress Payouts

Here is the section on limits and factors impacting emotional distress payouts rewritten in paragraph format:

Emotional distress compensation is influenced by certain legal limits and case-specific factors that weigh on the potential payout amounts. Some states impose caps on emotional distress awards, typically ranging from $250,000 to $500,000 in total allowable damages.

The severity of the misconduct causing distress also impacts scales, with intentional wrongdoing garnering higher compensation than mild negligence. Likewise, cases with clear medical histories substantiating trauma and supported by expert mental health testimony enable larger recoveries than speculative claims with minimal evidence tying distress to the incident.

Furthermore, comparative negligence principles reducing overall liability awards decrease emotional distress recoveries accordingly if any partial contributory fault by the plaintiff is established.

While no precise formulas exist, experienced attorneys can advise on state-specific limitations, carefully evaluate the strength of causation evidence provided, weigh the level of objectionable conduct based on facts, and estimate potential compensation ranges for the emotional damages being claimed based on judicial precedents and interpretation of merits.

Maximizing Emotional Distress Compensation

Plaintiffs can maximize potential payouts through:

  1. Documenting Mental Health Treatment: Providing records of counseling, prescriptions, and clinician testimony establishes a stronger claim.
  2. Proving Egregious Misconduct: Highlighting cruel, abusive, extreme wrongdoing by defendants warrants punitive damages.
  3. Securing Jury Sympathy: Graphically conveying mental anguish suffered stirs juror emotions to award greater compensation.
  4. Seeking Aggravated Awards: Pursuing enhanced damages by framing the conduct as willful or grossly negligent.

The more evidence confirming treatment, the more outrageous the actions, and the more sympathy stirred, the higher emotional distress verdicts and settlements typically rise.

FAQs on Emotional Distress Claims

What qualifies as emotional distress for a lawsuit?

Legally recognized emotional distress includes diagnosed mental health injuries like depression, anxiety, and PTSD that severely affect functioning.

How much money can you get for emotional distress?

There are no fixed limits, but emotional distress claims typically settle for anywhere from a few thousand to over $100k based on severity.

Is emotional distress hard to prove?

Emotional distress claims require meeting high standards of proof on the upsetting conduct and the extent of resultant mental health damages.

Do you need a lawyer to file for emotional distress?

While not legally required, consulting a personal injury attorney experienced with emotional distress lawsuits is highly advisable.

How do you claim emotional distress without medical records?

Circumstantial evidence like changed behaviors and testimony on trauma may help demonstrate emotional distress without medical documentation.

Can family members claim emotional distress?

Certain family members like parents or siblings may be able to make claims for negligent infliction of emotional distress in some states.

Does emotional distress compensation get taxed?

Taxability of emotional distress damages depends on the legal basis – physical injury portions are generally not taxable.

Can you sue just for emotional distress?

You typically cannot successfully sue solely for emotional distress absent physical harm or extreme conduct causing diagnosed mental trauma.

How long do you have to file an emotional distress lawsuit?

Deadlines are based on state statutes of limitations, but typically 1 to 3 years from the distressing incident.

How much emotional distress raises lawsuit potential?

Substantial emotional distress with diagnosed conditions like clinical depression, PTSD, and chronic anxiety warrants potential legal action.

Don’t Endure Psychological Harm Alone – Pursue Just Compensation

The emotional trauma of negligence or abuse can linger and manifest in PTSD, depression, and other destructive ways if left unaddressed. However, holding wrongdoers accountable through emotional distress claims can aid recovery and provide closure.

At Drake Injury Law Firm, we are committed advocates for clients suffering mental health damages from incidents like car accidents or harassment. We will pursue evidence gathering, secure expert testimonies, highlight egregious actions, and aggressively negotiate to maximize your rightful emotional distress compensation.

Call (205) 859-2236 or complete our secure online form to schedule your free case review now. We will fight to ease your anguish and suffering by obtaining the maximum allowable recovery.

You can heal knowing justice was served.

Drake Injury Lawyers
Average rating:  
 0 reviews